Home      Merch      shows      recipes      blog      forums      who      contact

You are not logged in.

#1 Fri 3/27/09 8:24 pm

eleanorbabyy
Top of the food chain & doesn't need to prove it
From: Tempeh, AZ
Registered: Tue 10/7/08
Posts: 616
Website

over-healthifying

have any of you guys ever over-healthified something? as in where you make a lot of little changes in a recipe to make it healthier that, on their own, would produce an end product just as delicious as the original, but the fact that you did all of them made a big difference?!

I just made vcon lower-fat banana bread with 6 Tbs applesauce and 2 Tbs oil (instead of 1/4 cup each), all whole wheat flour, and 1/3 cup date sugar instead of 1/2 cup reg. and the result is still tasty, but it's nowhere nearrrr as good as it usually is when i use whole wheat pastry flour and the regular sugar (i forget if i've done the extra apple sauce before). thank god i put in some chocolate chips or it would be like eating healthy banana cardboard slabs! (the best cardboard ever but still..)

anyways, what's everyone's opinion on how to draw the line on healthification and whether the amount of change in taste is worth the calories you save?! how far is too far and how do you know in advance? thanks!


"If you can't control your peanut butter, you can't expect to control your life." --Calvin & Hobbes

Pride & Vegudice: http://prideandvegudice.com

Offline

 

#2 Fri 3/27/09 8:37 pm

Rach-ums
The Real Hamburger Helper
From: You Ess Aye
Registered: Thu 3/6/08
Posts: 2280

Re: over-healthifying

That's so weird, i made vcon banana bread today too! I have a rule, half and half. Half healthy, half naughty. So I did half white flour, half whole wheat. Half oil, half applesauce (yes even in this recipe where it's already half applesauce). Half sugar, half no cal tumour death stuff (or agave if I have it). I thought it turned out well, but you have to be sure not to overstir!!! That's a big no-no.

Offline

 

#3 Fri 3/27/09 8:52 pm

melomeals
Inflexitarian
From: Portsmouth, NH
Registered: Sun 7/9/06
Posts: 765
Website

Re: over-healthifying

Almost everything I make is trying to overhealthify.. but it works out great most of the time. Especially with baked goods. I have really pushed the envelope there using mostly stevia and all whole wheat flour and only a tiny bit of oil..  my latest muffins used lentils and they were awesome. Totally kid approved (which is what I go by because they are always honest)

I've also found that using cooking with hardly any fat and pouring a tsp of olive oil on the plate just before serving really works well.

Offline

 

#4 Fri 3/27/09 8:56 pm

eleanorbabyy
Top of the food chain & doesn't need to prove it
From: Tempeh, AZ
Registered: Tue 10/7/08
Posts: 616
Website

Re: over-healthifying

Rach-ums, I guess there's just something in the air today (like ripe bananas...)

melomeals, where do you get your stevia and how do you know how much to use in replacement of sugar (what's the ratio?)! i'm interested in trying that!


"If you can't control your peanut butter, you can't expect to control your life." --Calvin & Hobbes

Pride & Vegudice: http://prideandvegudice.com

Offline

 

#5 Fri 3/27/09 9:46 pm

veggiewolverine
Addicted to B12 Enemas
Registered: Tue 7/22/08
Posts: 256

Re: over-healthifying

melomeals wrote:

my latest muffins used lentils and they were awesome.

im intrigued.  how do you use lentils in your baked goods?

Offline

 

#6 Fri 3/27/09 9:57 pm

elouise
Should Spend More Time Helping the Animals
From: Denver
Registered: Sat 2/11/06
Posts: 6164
Website

Re: over-healthifying

Unless I'm baking for other people, I usually healthify dessert/baked good recipes - whole wheat pastry flour, less fat, slightly less sugar, etc. I don't have a rule of thumb, per se, I guess I've just been baking long enough (and often enough!) that I know what will and won't work.


"Sarcasm is the refuge of losers."
"It is, really?"

Food blog

Offline

 

#7 Fri 3/27/09 10:10 pm

deepbluehue
Because Bob Barker Told Me To
From: Portland, OR
Registered: Tue 1/2/07
Posts: 940

Re: over-healthifying

One thing I picked up from the McDougall diet is using water instead of oil to cook with.  I find that it's useful sometimes, like for soups and sauces.  It's really hard to brown things with water, so I don't use it for everything.  Sometimes you need things to caramelize, like onions, and leaving out the oil does sacrifice flavor. 

I bought this cookbook called "Secrets of Fat-free Baking" about 13 years ago.  It had a recipe for whole wheat "Chocolate" raspberry cookies.  It tasted like wheaty cardboard jam crackers.  I would say that's a good example of going too far for a healthy treat.


I'm fairly sure I don't need bacon foam or emulsified bull balls on my parsnip gelee, anyway.~KarynMC
Fish aren't animals.  They are the fruit of the ocean.  "Fruit de Mer"...But have you seen those fruit SWIM?  Wow.~UnicornOnTheCob

My Artwork

Offline

 

#8 Fri 3/27/09 10:45 pm

melomeals
Inflexitarian
From: Portsmouth, NH
Registered: Sun 7/9/06
Posts: 765
Website

Re: over-healthifying

I use Kal Stevia (it's the only stevia I use)

http://www.myvitanet.com/pustexpo35oz.h … stexpo35oz

They say to use 1 teaspoon to replace a cup of sugar, but I've found that is way way too much. I use more like a scant 1/2 t.   I use it all the time to make KoolAid for my kids (sooo bad for you, but they love it)...

Here's the recipe for my breakfast muffins using lentils..

Breakfast Muffins/Cake

Wet Ingredients:
2 c chai tea
2 c cooked lentils
4 T fresh ginger
¾ c coconut
1 T cinnamon
1 t ground cloves
1 t coconut extract (or vanilla or almond)
¼ c flax meal
¼ t kal stevia (optional) or 4 t liquid sweetener
1 T vinegar

Dry Ingredients:
4 c whole wheat flour
1 T baking powder
1.5 t baking soda
½ c sugar
1 t salt
Optional: 1 c raisins

Method:
Pre-heat oven to 375

Place the wet ingredients in a blender and blend

Mix the dry ingredients in a mixing bowl, make a well and fold the wet ingredients in until just combined.

Spray a muffin tin with cooking spray and scoop a quarter  cup into the tins.  Bake for 15- 20 minutes or until a toothpick comes out clean.

Or spray a 9 by 13 baking pan and place mixture in there.

Here's a pic of them:
http://melomeals.blogspot.com/2009/03/3 … times.html

Bake for 30 minutes or until a toothpick comes out clean.

Last edited by melomeals (Fri 3/27/09 10:47 pm)

Offline

 

#9 Fri 3/27/09 10:49 pm

deepbluehue
Because Bob Barker Told Me To
From: Portland, OR
Registered: Tue 1/2/07
Posts: 940

Re: over-healthifying

That sounds really good.  I've never thought to try using lentils to cut the fat.  It probably adds a lot of good protein to your muffins.


I'm fairly sure I don't need bacon foam or emulsified bull balls on my parsnip gelee, anyway.~KarynMC
Fish aren't animals.  They are the fruit of the ocean.  "Fruit de Mer"...But have you seen those fruit SWIM?  Wow.~UnicornOnTheCob

My Artwork

Offline

 

#10 Fri 3/27/09 11:00 pm

melomeals
Inflexitarian
From: Portsmouth, NH
Registered: Sun 7/9/06
Posts: 765
Website

Re: over-healthifying

It sure does add the protein. I make muffins for my kids to grab early in the morning for breakfast... and want to get as much nutrition into them as possible! I freeze the muffins and we take them out the night before and let them thaw.

Offline

 

#11 Fri 3/27/09 11:12 pm

buddhist cupcake
Moving To Sheepshead Bay
From: the mitten
Registered: Wed 10/17/07
Posts: 5501
Website

Re: over-healthifying

i'm guilty of doing this all the time.
now i just bake things full fat, but less often, and i try to give more of the batch away to others.


"I'm so vegan, my breast implants are made of tofu ricotta." - dial
"buddhist cupcake is an illusion. the taste is in your mind. you must let go of your desire for flavor." -acr
add me on facebook! --> http://www.facebook.com/msktrose

Offline

 

#12 Fri 3/27/09 11:48 pm

eleanorbabyy
Top of the food chain & doesn't need to prove it
From: Tempeh, AZ
Registered: Tue 10/7/08
Posts: 616
Website

Re: over-healthifying

thanks melomeals! i'll have to try that recipe some time!

does stevia have any sort of weird taste associated with it? slash can you definitely tell there's no sugar in the baked goods? it almost seems too good to be true, which is why i ask smile


"If you can't control your peanut butter, you can't expect to control your life." --Calvin & Hobbes

Pride & Vegudice: http://prideandvegudice.com

Offline

 

#13 Sat 3/28/09 1:08 am

onepomegranate
Lactose Intolerant...Literally
Registered: Sun 4/8/07
Posts: 695

Re: over-healthifying

I healthify Everything and I'm not interested in eating things that aren't healthified and actually prefer the taste.  (no white flour, refined stuff, etc.)   I do know what you --sometimes it doesn't really work out, but better to try anyway, I think.

Offline

 

#14 Sat 3/28/09 8:51 am

matwinser
totally heinous dickwad
From: Three Bridges
Registered: Mon 12/12/05
Posts: 2565
Website

Re: over-healthifying

Rach-ums wrote:

no cal tumour death stuff

Please let this be their new offcial marketing campaign!

Mat.

Offline

 

#15 Sat 3/28/09 9:41 am

melomeals
Inflexitarian
From: Portsmouth, NH
Registered: Sun 7/9/06
Posts: 765
Website

Re: over-healthifying

yeah.. stevia DOES have a weired taste, but for me, KAL is the best and you have to use a small amount of it. I've played around with it enough to figure out the right balance. I usually use a little bit of sugar and the stevia.. and you can't tell at all. I've made a fair share of things with only stevia and they're not great. The recipe I posted uses 1/2 cup of sugar for 24 muffins.. so it comes out to very little in each muffin.

Now in cooking, I use stevia all the time in bbq sauce and things like that and it works great.

Offline

 

#16 Sat 3/28/09 10:17 am

BananaNut
Drinks Wild Tofurkey
From: North Carolina
Registered: Sun 8/31/08
Posts: 2892
Website

Re: over-healthifying

I healthify almost everything too. I don't go crazy with each recipe, but I try to make improvements where I can. If I'm baking I'll usually sub at least half of the flour with whole wheat or spelt flour, and replace some of the fat. I do it with non-baking recipes too.

Offline

 

#17 Sat 3/28/09 11:19 am

ameyfm
Has it on Blue Vinyl
From: Santa Cruz
Registered: Mon 2/6/06
Posts: 2193
Website

Re: over-healthifying

BananaNut wrote:

I healthify almost everything too. I don't go crazy with each recipe, but I try to make improvements where I can. If I'm baking I'll usually sub at least half of the flour with whole wheat or spelt flour, and replace some of the fat. I do it with non-baking recipes too.

yeah, this is my approach. Cut back on the fat a bit, sometimes cut back on salt, always half whole grain flour... In some recipes I really drastically cut back on fat... but it has taken me some experience to know when you can and when you can't .

On occasion though, I have totally overdone the healthifying! I definitely know what you mean.


may all beings everywhere be peaceful and free
Human News is not the only news

Vegan Blog : Painting : Yoga

Offline

 

#18 Sat 3/28/09 1:47 pm

JackyVeg
Level 7 Vegan
From: PR
Registered: Fri 5/2/08
Posts: 1576

Re: over-healthifying

Rach-ums wrote:

That's so weird, i made vcon banana bread today too! I have a rule, half and half. Half healthy, half naughty. So I did half white flour, half whole wheat. Half oil, half applesauce (yes even in this recipe where it's already half applesauce). Half sugar, half no cal tumour death stuff (or agave if I have it). I thought it turned out well, but you have to be sure not to overstir!!! That's a big no-no.

i do this too, sometimes. the half and half when baking; because at least you know that the final product will taste good and you're not ruining the ingredients.

Offline

 

#19 Sat 3/28/09 2:30 pm

Vijita
Dr Bronners, MD
From: San Francisco
Registered: Sun 1/6/08
Posts: 4860

Re: over-healthifying

ameyfm wrote:

BananaNut wrote:

I healthify almost everything too. I don't go crazy with each recipe, but I try to make improvements where I can. If I'm baking I'll usually sub at least half of the flour with whole wheat or spelt flour, and replace some of the fat. I do it with non-baking recipes too.

yeah, this is my approach. Cut back on the fat a bit, sometimes cut back on salt, always half whole grain flour... In some recipes I really drastically cut back on fat... but it has taken me some experience to know when you can and when you can't .

On occasion though, I have totally overdone the healthifying! I definitely know what you mean.

+1 on pretty much all regards.

One thing I stick to though...NEVER healthify vegan recipes for vegan-skeptic omni's. They need every little bit fatty surgary oily salty bit of vegan food goodness to shut up with the critiquing. It's funny too, because they usually assume it must be exceedingly healthy since it doesn't *gasp* contain lard, meat, etc etc etc. Makes me chuckle while dumping a 1/2 cup of oil into the white flour for the chocolate chip cookies. wink

One pattern I've noticed in my own consumption is that I make something decadent (ex: a dessert or fatty entree without healthful substitutions), my body naturally craves much lighter accompaniments and I feel like it evens out in the end, without sacrificing taste. For example, I LOVE a light salad meal, but after said meal if I have a gooey brownie or something I feel much more balanced and healthy than if I were to make a super-reduced fat noodle dish or casserole or something and then waste a batch of perfectly good cookies on overly healthificated dry biscuits. Additionally, a heavy veggie burger begs to be accompanied by salad rather than fried in most cases.

Obviously, moderation is key.

Also....when I (like last night) go out with friends and drink a bit too much wine and come home to gorge on a pretty greasy grilled "cheese" with tempeh bacon late at night, the next morning (this morning) I wake up and only want to eat raw fruits and veggies until the evening. It's amazing how much our bodies and appetites can tell us if we listen.

Offline

 

#20 Sat 3/28/09 2:35 pm

seitanicverses
Loves Elephants!
From: Toronto, Ontario CANADA
Registered: Tue 1/10/06
Posts: 17015

Re: over-healthifying

I used to do this but now I don't.  Sometimes, I'll cut the oil in salad dressings or sauteing oil but other than that, I don't sweat it.  I feel properly full when I leave the oils and fats alone.  I remember when I used to sub out much of the oils in cooking years ago (I went through this phase), my stomach still felt empty like I'd just eaten paper of something of no substance.  Those were the days! 

And yes, if cooking vegan for non-vegans, definitely leave the oil, sugars and salts alone without subbing to the point of fat and taste-freeishness.

Offline

 

#21 Sat 3/28/09 2:55 pm

ameyfm
Has it on Blue Vinyl
From: Santa Cruz
Registered: Mon 2/6/06
Posts: 2193
Website

Re: over-healthifying

seitanicverses wrote:

And yes, if cooking vegan for non-vegans, definitely leave the oil, sugars and salts alone without subbing to the point of fat and taste-freeishness.

Agreed!
First we must impress them... woo them over to the light side. Then, we can mess with their food!
smile


may all beings everywhere be peaceful and free
Human News is not the only news

Vegan Blog : Painting : Yoga

Offline

 

#22 Sat 3/28/09 11:39 pm

eleanorbabyy
Top of the food chain & doesn't need to prove it
From: Tempeh, AZ
Registered: Tue 10/7/08
Posts: 616
Website

Re: over-healthifying

Vijita wrote:

ameyfm wrote:

BananaNut wrote:

I healthify almost everything too. I don't go crazy with each recipe, but I try to make improvements where I can. If I'm baking I'll usually sub at least half of the flour with whole wheat or spelt flour, and replace some of the fat. I do it with non-baking recipes too.

yeah, this is my approach. Cut back on the fat a bit, sometimes cut back on salt, always half whole grain flour... In some recipes I really drastically cut back on fat... but it has taken me some experience to know when you can and when you can't .

On occasion though, I have totally overdone the healthifying! I definitely know what you mean.

+1 on pretty much all regards.

One thing I stick to though...NEVER healthify vegan recipes for vegan-skeptic omni's. They need every little bit fatty surgary oily salty bit of vegan food goodness to shut up with the critiquing. It's funny too, because they usually assume it must be exceedingly healthy since it doesn't *gasp* contain lard, meat, etc etc etc. Makes me chuckle while dumping a 1/2 cup of oil into the white flour for the chocolate chip cookies. wink

One pattern I've noticed in my own consumption is that I make something decadent (ex: a dessert or fatty entree without healthful substitutions), my body naturally craves much lighter accompaniments and I feel like it evens out in the end, without sacrificing taste. For example, I LOVE a light salad meal, but after said meal if I have a gooey brownie or something I feel much more balanced and healthy than if I were to make a super-reduced fat noodle dish or casserole or something and then waste a batch of perfectly good cookies on overly healthificated dry biscuits. Additionally, a heavy veggie burger begs to be accompanied by salad rather than fried in most cases.

Obviously, moderation is key.

Also....when I (like last night) go out with friends and drink a bit too much wine and come home to gorge on a pretty greasy grilled "cheese" with tempeh bacon late at night, the next morning (this morning) I wake up and only want to eat raw fruits and veggies until the evening. It's amazing how much our bodies and appetites can tell us if we listen.

Funny you mention that last part, because last night I DID in fact drink too much wine, and I got back to my dorm room with the drunkie munchies and ate like a BIGASS chunk of said banana bread that inspired this thread (i may have over-healthified it, but it's still plenty chocolate chippy, and if you eat enough of anything...). And, yeah, exactly like you said, I woke up and had a huge plate of fresh honeydew, cantaloupe, and pineapple for breakfast.

Oh, and another funny thing...when I first woke up in the morning, I had a horrible hangover and felt really hot and dehydrated. The only liquid in my mini dorm fridge was a container of Silk Light Vanilla. I may or may not have chugged an unhealthy amount of it in my desperation.

Last edited by eleanorbabyy (Sat 3/28/09 11:40 pm)


"If you can't control your peanut butter, you can't expect to control your life." --Calvin & Hobbes

Pride & Vegudice: http://prideandvegudice.com

Offline

 

#23 Sun 3/29/09 12:31 am

CrocOdile
Remembers When Veganism Was Cool
From: chicago
Registered: Tue 2/28/06
Posts: 2544

Re: over-healthifying

i can never tell the difference when i stick to the "half" rule--half regular, half healthy version (whole wheat pastry flour, applesauce, whatever). i stick with evaporated cane juice, though, that might help.

you know what recipe tastes really good almost completely healthified? the apple pie crumb cake muffins from vwav.


"Perhaps only vegans shove garlic up their goldmines." - Sarita

Offline

 

#24 Sun 3/29/09 1:36 am

vallen
Ingrid Newkirk's Baby Daddy
From: Austin, Texas
Registered: Sun 10/21/07
Posts: 289

Re: over-healthifying

I've over-healthified things for several years now.... But I baked with a friend last weekend who wanted to follow the recipes to a T and I found that I just couldn't eat the over-sweet baked goods. I've ruined myself for over-sweet things forever! ^^;; Oh well, I suppose it is for the best in the long run.

Offline

 

#25 Sun 3/29/09 4:12 pm

sarchan
Plotting a Vegan Coup
From: Greenpoint
Registered: Wed 3/1/06
Posts: 4356
Website

Re: over-healthifying

melomeals wrote:

2 c cooked lentils

What kind of lentils do you use? Do you think toor dal or chana dal would work out okay?

I'm very intrigued and I usually adore chai-flavored anything.

Offline

 

Board footer

Powered by PunBB
© Copyright 2002–2005 Rickard Andersson